Tuesday, August 5, 2008

Claim Interpretation

One of the trends that I am seeing at the patent office is a tendency by Examiners to broaden the claims beyond the context provided in the specification. This allows references to be cited that would otherwise not read on the claims, if the claims were properly interpreted in light of the specification and the level of skill of a person having ordinary skill in the pertinent field. There was a time when precedent of the Court of Appeals of the Federal Circuit supported reading the claim language broadly, according to its plain meaning or a dictionary definition. That time has past. The precedent of the Federal Circuit and the U.S. Supreme Court has established that Applicant’s specification is the best source for determining what the claims mean. Thus, now more than ever, both the drafting of a system of claims that protects all of the aspects of the invention and the context provided by the written description are critical to obtaining the proper scope of protection in an application filed with the United States Patent & Trademark Office. The increasing importance of the specification for interpreting the meaning of the claims means that most clients will be better served by developing long term relationships with a competent, local patent counsel that develops an intimate knowledge of the technology and business goals of the client.

The claims of a patent set the scope of protection granted by the patent.
Phillips v. AWH Corp., 415 F.3d 1303, 1312 (Fed.Cir.2005). However, in construing what the claims mean, the patent office must determine what the claim language of the claims would have meant to a person having ordinary skill in the relevant art at the time of the invention within the context provided by the specification. Id. at 1313. According to precedent, the hypothetical “person of ordinary skill in the art” interprets the meaning of the claims after having read the entire patent and within the context of the patent as a whole. Id. The specification--and other intrinsic evidence, such as the prosecution history and the language of other claims--often provides the best indicator of the meaning of claim language. Id. at 1314-15. Provided that due caution is exercised to avoid reading limitations from the specification into the claims, the specification is "…the single best guide to the meaning of a disputed claim term…" and is usually dispositive. Id. at 1315 and 1323 (quoting Vitronics Corp. v. Conceptronic, Inc., 90 F.3d 1576, 1582 (Fed.Cir.1996)).

The patent protects the entire scope of the invention as stated in the claim, not merely the example or examples of the invention provided in the specification. See
415 F.3d at 1312. However, any interpretation of the claims must be equally careful to avoid reading the claims too broadly, as would be done if the claims terms are defined according to dictionary definitions rather than in the context of the specification. Id. at 1321. While extrinsic evidence, such as learned treatises and technical dictionaries, may be consulted, the purpose of such extrinsic evidence is limited. Extrinsic evidence merely provides "…background on the technology at issue, to explain how an invention works…” or ensures that the Examiner's “…understanding of the technical aspects of the patent is consistent with that of a person having ordinary skill in the art…” or establishes that a particular claim term has a particular meaning within the context of the specification or within the pertinent field. Id. at 1318. Again, the specification is the best source for determining the meaning of a claim term, and assertions of what a claim term means that are not supported by the specification, prosecution history or the prior art in the pertinent field are not useful. Id.

The strongest patent protection is provided by having competent, local patent counsel working closely with the inventors to describe the background of the invention and to prepare a written description that provides context to the language used in the claims. Development of the context needed to support the claims is enhanced by early and frequent contact between patent counsel and the inventors involved in the research and development process. Thus, the patent process benefits from a close proximity between a local patent counsel and the client. The failures and technical challenges faced during reduction of an invention to practice establish a context for defining the patentable features of the claims that are nonobvious over the state of the art at the time that the invention is made. The technical vocabulary developed during close collaboration between local patent counsel and the inventors is invaluable in the understanding of the invention and the defnition of the claim language used in the drafting of strong patent protection. Furthermore, a local patent counsel working closely with inventors is much more likely to be able to identify measurements and comparisons that may be made during evaluation of a new technology, which can be used to distinguish the new technology over the prior art, providing “objective evidence of nonobviousness” such as synergistic results or results that are surprising and unexpected, which is the sin qua non for patentability post-KSR.
[1]

Finally, if an ongoing relationship exits between local patent counsel and both top management and the innovators of a client, then patent counsel is much more capable of identifying those particular discoveries and improvements over the prior art that warrant patent protection: inventions with features distinguishable over the known prior art, inventions having important applications within the field of the client or within a field of a potential licensee, and inventions that are aligned with the business goals of the client and support the business objectives of the client. When this type of integration of the client and local patent counsel is achieved, the drafting of a system of patent claims that are fully supported and adequately defined within the context of the written description of the specification is not difficult. The claim terms are defined using the language adopted by innovators within the particular field and defined by the written description, providing no room for abusive over-broadening by the patent office. More importantly, the scope of the claims protected by patenting is not selected merely for ease of patenting or for incremental improvements. Instead, a consistent framework is established for the language used in the claims within the context of the written descriptions across the entire patent portfolio, which strengthens all of the issued patents and pending applications within the enterprise’s intellectual property portfolio.


[1] In KSR v. Teleflex the U.S. Supreme Court overruled the Federal Circuit’s rigid application of the TSM test and instead relied on earlier precedent that patent examiners and the courts must consider (1) the scope and content of the prior art, (2) the differences between the claimed invention and the prior art, (3) the level of ordinary skill in the pertinent art, and (4) objective evidence relevant to the issue of obviousness, when determining if a claim is nonobvious over the prior art. (For an introduction to patentability post-KSR see http://www.bpcouncil.com/apage/488.php.)

Tuesday, June 10, 2008

IP ASSESSMENT

Any intellectual property assessment starts not with a catalogue of patents, but with a definition of strategic business goals and an IP vision. Then, an IP analysis system may be devised that fits the IP vision of the company. Tools may be selected to develop information, quantifiable or qualitative, capable of supporting IP management decisions directed to achieving the IP vision of the company.

Is the company looking to out-license some or all of its patent portfolio to others? Is the company looking to acquire companies with strategic IP assets in areas identified for strategic business development? Is the company trying to avoid IP infringement lawsuits by buying or licensing IP rights that might be acquired by others? Is the company looking to identify directions for targeted innovation for developing new markets? Each of these require a different type of search and different information to support decision making by company management.

Patent search and mapping tools offered by Delphion (clustering) and Micropatent (Aureka) are decent commercial tools for patent assessment, provided that a sufficient number of issued and published patent applications are available within the selected field(s) of interest to warrant the use of these tools. A patent specialist or paralegal may be trained to use these tools. Otherwise, it is best to develop a long term relationship with outside patent counsel capable of providing patent, trademark and copyright searches and IP due diligence using tools available to them.

Nothing beats a intellectual property attorney with the technical expertise and experience in using or understanding the available tools and a staff capable of providing initial keyword searches to identify relevant search terms and to analyze intellectual property assets, such as patent claims and written descriptions. A long term relationship with in house or outside counsel having a strong technical background in the related art and an understanding of your company's needs for information to support business decisions is essential to implementation of an IP vision.

A snapshot provided by a single report is only marginally useful and will soon be outdated. Continuous tracking of trends and the ability to identify opportunities aligned with the IP vision is far more useful. A long term relationship with IP counsel supporting an IP assessment provides benefits in the quality of the analysis, which goes beyond patent mapping of specifications, titles and abstracts and includes analysis of the claims, file histories and written descriptions within key areas of innovation. Patent counsel may provide information useful to key decision makers based on the reports and in depth analysis that goes beyond the reports and metrics used to keep management informed of the status of the company’s IP portfolio and strategic investments. If the IP vision is understood by the entire enterprise, then information developed using data mining tools will be supplemented by information from employees, such as the sales force, technical specialists and managers, provided that some system is in place to capture such information.

If the IP vision includes development of an ongoing out-licensing, innovation development or acquisition strategy, then adequate resources must be committed to the endeavor and senior management must be willing to be actively involved in formulating the IP vision and in managing the IP assets and the allocation of resources in support of the IP vision. IP management and analysis tools may be used for gathering specific information about company IP, providing patent mapping reports to support business decisions, presenting relevant relationships between IP clusters, identifying directions for new development, identifying corporate IP assets for out-licensing opportunities, and finding IP assets that may be beneficial targets for acquisition or in-licensing. Any use of such tools should support the IP vision and must be incorporated into the company decision making process. Decision makers must be familiar with the information that may be presented by such tools and how such tools may be understood and used by decision makers to evaluate IP assets of the company and to identify opportunities furthering the company’s IP vision.

A system must be provided for evaluation of IP assessment reports, identifying opportunities, making management decisions supporting the IP vision, and updating of the company’s IP vision.

Wednesday, May 14, 2008

Privilege, Willfulness & In re Seagate

Any litigation may come back to haunt a company that does not carefully consider the impact of broad discovery rules under the Federal Rules of Evidence. Discovery may lead to disclosure of trade secrets and privileged information that the company would rather keep confidential. Thus, a company should not lightly initiate a lawsuit or take any action that might provide a basis for a competitor to bring a lawsuit against it. Some examples of activities that may give rise to litigation by one’s competitors include advertising, use of trademarks, claims of patent or trademark infringement, licensing activities and sales of products or services that might give rise to a third party patent infringement lawsuit.

While it is prudent to seek the advice of legal counsel prior to making business decisions, the protection provided to legal advice in litigation must be considered in determining how confidential attorney-client communications are used and disclosed. Disclosing attorney-client privileged communications may have far reaching and unintended consequences. While the attorney work product privilege and attorney-client privilege provide some protection for information requested by an attorney in anticipation of a litigation, the privilege ultimately fails to shield some tests, opinions of counsel and reports. The purpose of the attorney work product privilege is to shield work product that is prepared under the direction of an attorney, and the privilege is related to the attorney-client privilege. However, the work product privilege is narrower than the attorney-client privilege, because it only protects work product that would not have been prepared except for the anticipation of litigation.

A recent decision by U.S. District Court Judge Richard J. Sullivan of the Southern District of New York should be a reminder that any advertising claims should be carefully vetted, and business risk analysis should consider carefully the consequences of broad discovery rules. In this decision, the defendant was required to disclose confidential testing information in a lawsuit claiming false advertising under the Lanham Act and the New York Consumer Protection Act . The Procter & Gamble Company (P&G) claimed that advertising claims of Ultreo, Inc. (Ultreo), about the ultrasound wave technology of Ultreo’s ultrasonic toothbrush, were misleading to consumers. P&G sought laboratory and clinical testing and reports of Ultreo that related to the false advertising claims. Ultreo was compelled to produce such reports, and P&G was entitled to consider them in its action for false advertising. Ultreo sought to protect some of the reports from disclosure under attorney work product protections. According to the court, however, it is not enough for a report to be performed in anticipation of litigation. Utreo must be able to show that the reports “would not have been prepared in substantially similar form but for the prospect of litigation.” According to the court, Ultreo failed to meet its burden to show that these reports were shielded by the attorney work product privilege, and Ultreo was compelled to disclose the protocols, data and final results of the studies.

In another example, attorney work product privilege was denied for patent searches conducted in anticipation of litigation, even though attorney advice was obtained based on the searches. The defendant in Takeda was found to have regularly conducted patent searches in the course of its business. Thus, the court held that the specific patent search results and related strategies were not shielded by the attorney work product privilege. While the Takeda decision is not applicable to attorney advice based on the results, a party can infer a great deal from a patent search and patent search strategy, when it is disclosed in litigation discovery.

Reasonably relying on a sound, pre-litigation written opinion prepared by competent patent counsel provides a degree of immunity to charges of willfulness, but potentially opens up any pre-litigation advice about infringement and invalidity by litigation counsel to discovery by the plaintiff. A written opinion of counsel relating to invalidity or infringement is protected by attorney-client privilege only if the written opinion is kept secret. A defendant is immunized against willful infringement based on reasonable reliance on the written opinion of an experienced patent attorney, showing that all of the claims at issue in the patent litigation are either invalid or not infringed. It should come as no surprise that use of a defendant’s reliance on a pre-litigation “opinion of counsel” as a defense to willful infringement strips the attorney-client privilege and work product privilege for the opinion, because the plaintiff is entitled to investigate if the reliance on the opinion was reasonable. Use of this defense, makes all related opinions discoverable by the plaintiff and not just the one chosen by the defendant, because the other opinions might make it more or less reasonable for the defendant to rely on the opinion offered.

However, an opinion by the U.S. Court of Appeals for the Federal Circuit in In Re Seagate overturns longstanding precedent and sets a standard of “objective recklessness” for determining if a defendant’s infringement is willful and subject to enhanced damages, and the same decision shields post-litigation opinions of litigation counsel from discovery. While the standard in Seagate is likely to diminish the risk to defendants of an award of enhanced damages, which may be up to three times the actual damages, some companies will still seek pre-litigation opinions of noninfringement and invalidity as a defense against possible charges of willful infringement. Formal opinions of counsel may be required in certain deals licensing patented technology or in mergers and acquisitions, for example. In addition, a reasonable reliance on a sound opinion of counsel is likely to be an even more effective defense against willfulness under the heightened standard of objective recklessness than it was previously.

A standard of “objectively unreasonable” in a concurring opinion is different from the standard of the majority opinion, which requires the plaintiff to establish “objective recklessness” prior to any subjective determinations. According to the majority opinion of the en banc panel in In re Seagate, an objective recklessness standard should be applied when determining whether enhanced damages for willful infringement are warranted. According to the majority opinion, the “objective recklessness” standard likely lessens the defendant’s burden in rebutting willfulness to only a showing of a “substantial question” as to invalidity and non-infringement, which is the same standard capable of defeating a motion for preliminary injunction. Depending on the standard that the courts ultimately adopt, the likelihood of successfully meeting the threshold for requiring a showing of subjective reasonableness by a defendant may be greatly diminished following In Re Seagate. Whenever the risk of litigation warrants a review of a particular patent, any company that can afford to have a formal written opinion prepared by an independent, experienced patent counsel should consider engaging opinion counsel, prior to making a business decision to sell a product that might give rise to a patent infringement lawsuit.

However, some companies refrain from introducing a formal written opinion, prepared in advance of litigation, due to the effect of discovery rules on attorney-client privileged communications with their litigation counsel. Prior to In Re Seagate, introducing the opinion of counsel defense opened not only the opinion counsel to scrutiny during discovery but also trial counsel’s advice and opinions were subjected to the same scrutiny in some cases. The court in Seagate balanced the interests in discovery with the attorney-client privilege, allowing for discovery of all pre-litigation opinions provided for making informed business decisions, while drawing the line at discovery of post-litigation advice of litigation counsel. The opinion of In Re Seagate does not address the case when opinion and litigation counsel are one and the same; therefore, advice given post-litigation might be discoverable in determining if the defendant reasonably relied on the pre-litigation advice of the same patent counsel.

For now, if a company might desire to introduce its reliance on a pre-litigation opinion of counsel as a defense to willfulness, then the company should select different firms for post-litigation defense of a patent infringement lawsuit and any pre-litigation opinions of counsel.

There also is an unanswered question about any privilege that is offered for pre-litigation advice of litigation counsel. The opinion in In Re Seagate applies, directly, only to post-litigation advice of litigation counsel. Pre-litigation advice might not be offered any attorney-client and work product privileges. If the company routinely relies on objective assessment of opinions of counsel for making informed business decisions, then the work product privilege probably does not apply. An analogy may be made with the work product privilege in Takeda, for example, which makes patent search strategies and results discoverable based on the routine use of patent searches in making business decisions. Therefore, there is a substantial risk than any pre-litigation opinion of litigation counsel may become discoverable, if the defendant ultimately presents a defense to willfulness based on reliance upon any pre-litigation advice of counsel.

If there is a substantial risk relating to certain specific patents, a company probably should still seek an independent pre-litigation opinion, as an insurance policy against the plaintiff making its showing of “objective recklessness.” A pre-litigation opinion should be provided by an experienced patent attorney from a firm other than the firm that will be chosen to defend any patent infringement litigation.

The primary purpose of any legal opinion should always be for use in making a business decision, preferably prior to infringing a related patent or within a reasonable time after discovering the existence of such a patent. Any opinion that might be used as a defense to willfulness should be a formal written opinion of invalidity or non-infringement or both, because it is more reasonable to rely on a formal, complete, and thorough written opinion than on a less formal opinion. The cost of a formal written opinion, which may be more than twenty thousand dollars per patent and sometimes considerably more, is nevertheless a comparatively inexpensive defense against a debilitating award of enhanced damages. The formality of a written opinion is needed to make it effective in raising an opinion of counsel defense against enhanced damages, if the need arises. However, there is some room for separating out routine legal opinions merely for use in making business decisions and formal legal opinions for defending against a successful showing of objective recklessness in infringing a patent.

The opinion in In Re Seagate makes clear that there is little benefit to preparing a formal written opinion after a patent litigation is commenced.

Since any pre-litigation opinion of litigation counsel may be subject to discovery, in an abundance of caution, litigation counsel might forego pre-litigation analysis and advice. Instead, prior to litigation, the litigation counsel might rely on the formal opinion of a separate opinion counsel from a different firm in advising the client, subject to the caveat that litigation counsel has not formed an independent legal opinion as to invalidity and infringement. At least, it would be best for litigation counsel to refrain from offering any pre-litigation opinions about infringement or invalidity of the claims to any decision maker in the business. Advice by litigation counsel could reasonably be considered in determining whether continued reliance on an opinion earlier prepared by opinion counsel was reasonable under the circumstances. A practical problem arises, because advice from litigation counsel is usually not objective and is often the most pessimistic of advice. Litigation counsel is compelled to present a range of possible outcomes to a client, including the worst possible outcome. The alternative theories of litigation counsel are not intended to be an objective determination of infringement or validity. Instead, litigation counsel should consider the case from all angles, including that most favorable to the plaintiff. Indeed, this is the only way of assessing whether dismissal is appropriate. In light of Seagate, unless the client is willing to cease any infringing activities based on a worst case assessment of litigation counsel, such a frank assessment should probably not be shared with the client until after litigation is commenced, because if presented to the client prior to onset of litigation, such a worst case assessment is possibly discoverable.

The only times that it makes sense for litigation counsel to offer pre-litigation advice regarding infringement and validity is when the client is capable of acting on the advice to mitigate damages and when the client does not have any opinion of non-infringement or invalidity.

Especially if advice of litigation counsel would differ substantially from the assessment of the opinion counsel, sharing of any such advice by the litigation counsel with the client prior to the initiation of a litigation might prevent the unfettered use of an objective opinion, which might otherwise immunize the client against a charge of willful infringement. In the alternative, if the advice of litigation counsel does not differ substantially from that of the opinion counsel, then it is of limited usefulness, and there is no advantage in offering it to the client. If a pre-litigation opinion of counsel is on hand, then any discovery of a litigation counsel’s speculative pre-litigation assessments undoubtedly will be used against the opinion counsel’s assessment, which may well be the more reasoned, objective opinion. Of course, plaintiff’s counsel will present any differences in the two assessments in the most damaging light possible.

Wednesday, February 27, 2008

THE STUFF DREAMS ARE MADE OF

A recent article published by the Associated Press, claims that the estate of J.R.R. Tolkien was promised 7.5% of the take in the Lord of the Rings movie trilogy. "New Line has not paid the plaintiffs even one penny of its contractual share of gross receipts despite the billions of dollars of gross revenue generated by these wildly successful motion pictures," according to Steven Maier, an attorney for the Tolkien estate. So, why has New Line only paid the author's estate $62,500 in an up front payment, according to the Associate Press article?

Without reading the agreement between the estate and New Line, this question cannot be answered with any certainty. Did New Line agree to pay 7.5% of the “gross,” reportedly $6 billion, worldwide? Or did New Line only agree to pay 7.5% of some net receipts? The terms of a deal and the basis for the royalty are issues to address with a clever and experienced attorney prior to accepting any advance or signing any agreement within the entertainment industry. Often, the definitions in an agreement are far more important than the license grant and royalty rate, combined. Unfortunately, a term like "gross receipts" can be defined within nested definitions to be anything but gross revenues.

Without a doubt, 7.5% of $6 billion is a lot more than $62,500. You don't need an accountant to calculate the zeroes left off the amount paid. However, the motion picture industry, the music business, the theatre and the publishing industry are well known for a history of creative accounting. It is no laughing matter when an artist or writer learns that he or she owes money to the producer or publisher, rather than the other way around. Box office receipts are only a fraction of the total take of a blockbuster movie. Often, box office receipts may barely cover production, talent, distribution and marketing costs. It is easy for a studio to show a net loss compared only to box office receipts. When it comes time to divvy up the profits, somehow, even the biggest blockbuster at the box office finds a way to fizzle on its balance sheets.

With a project like The Lord of The Rings, the estate of the copyright owner could have required minimum amounts paid annually for the exclusive rights (expecting production delays) in addition to any future royalties. The revenue basis should not have been limited to box office receipts. Licensor will want the basis to be gross revenues and to have gross revenues defined as broadly as possible to capture every source of revenue, including toys, games, broadcast rights, foreign rights, advertising rights and cross-marketing. In short, every source of revenue, whether cash or a cash equivalent, should be included as revenue. Audit rights should be included, which provides a look at the books without resorting to litigation, and a single entity should be required to maintain a single set of books. Likewise, deductions from the gross revenue should be as limited as possible, if any. This would put the copyright holder in first place ahead of talent, composers, investors, producers, directors, family and friends of the producers and "others who are owed money for past productions that failed to even cover production costs that the producers feel ethically or morally compelled to compensate using someone else's money." (The money must be going somewhere!) You get the picture. Payroll can swell in big budget production. Even better, agree to take a smaller share of the gross revenue and save some money on your auditor’s bill. Finally, is a lump sum payment, made in advance, an advance on royalties or is it an advance payment in addition to any royalties paid later? So long as the advance is nonrefundable, why not take the money up front, if offered. But, don't count on seeing royalties any time soon. If the estate of J.R.R. Tolkien is going to court to try to collect its share of $6 billion, you can be sure that many other authors with less cachet are still waiting for their royalty checks. Find a good agent and a good attorney before you sign any agreement in the entertainment industry.